Showing posts with label fly. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fly. Show all posts

Friday, May 13, 2011

Pawpaws and Pollinators

With large, tropical-looking leaves, and a dark, mysterious flower, the Pawpaw (Asimina triloba) is the kind of tree Tennessee Williams would have planted next to the magnolias, if he had been into gardening. The blooms look like a dark red bell hanging below the branch. The dark color makes them less than showy than a Flowering Dogwood, but attractive, especially when backlit by the afternoon sun. It’s the classic Missouri bottomland tree, but when I mention that it’s pollinated by flies because the bloom looks like roadkilll—well, it turns people off.

I wrote about Pawpaw’s relationships with butterflies and moths last July. Still, people imagine, as I did, a Pawpaw in bloom, swarming with big hairy flies and a putrid odor wafting on the wind. Nothing could be farther from the truth. I took the photo above on April 20, but when I downloaded it from the camera and the photo filled the screen, I saw the flies for the first time. The flower was about 2 inches across at its widest point. I would have had to wear my reading glasses to see the flies.

Pawpaws don’t make it easy on a pollinator. To bear fruit, the bloom needs pollen from an unrelated Pawpaw. What’s more, process depends on a pollinator that is believed to be inefficient, sloppy, and promiscuous—that is, it’s like to visit many things other than a bloom of a Pawpaw.
Gosh, the flower looks alarmingly fleshy in this extreme crop! Those flies look pretty scary too, but the red eyes in the photo are caused by the flash.
  
Ted MacRae at Beetles in the Bush wrote about Pawpaws last May. In comments,  James Trager, entomologist and restoration biologist at Shaw Nature Reserve, wrote that the tree is likely pollinated by fungus gnats. Fungus gnats are important pollinators, but the critters in my photo don’t have the comparatively long legs I associate with gnats.

I posted my photo on Bug Guide to ask for some ID help.  One person suggested that they could be lesser dung flies. I estimated that the fly was 2 mm long or less—about the right size for dung fly family (Sphaeroceridae).  The Wikipedia article states that dung fly larvae eat fungus or bacteria on rotting vegetation. Another user on Bug Guide suggested that because the blossoms are stinky, they must be some type of carrion fly. That brings us to the next question, what does a Pawpaw blossom smell like? 

I headed out to the tree again and got up close and personal with the flower. It didn’t smell like roadkill, or dung—it had just the faintest odor of yeast. I could only detect the scent when my nose touched the bloom. Of course, yeast is a fungus, so fungus gnats and lots of other decomposers should find the fragrance attractive. But why be shy about the aroma if the plant really wants to be pollinated? 

I have some ideas about that. First, just because the odor is hard for me to detect doesn’t mean that it’s hard for insects to find. Although I had been thinking that there was only one specialized organism that pollinated Pawpaws, I found this statement in a 2001 article in Ecology and Society by Carol Ann Kearns:  "Many species of flies are generalists that visit multiple plant species." There are probably a number of different fly families that offer their pollination services to Pawpaw, though the flies don't seem to get any reward. 

Second, it's possible Pawpaw is a bit conflicted about this whole fruiting process. According to California Rare Fruit Growers, because each bloom has more than one ovary, "a single flower can produce multiple fruits." Add to that this advice to growers resorting to hand pollination, from a 1990 article from 
Kentucky State University Cooperative Extension Program: "
Do not overburden the tree with fruit, as this will stress the tree, resulting in smaller than normal fruit, and may cause limbs to break under excessive weight." Perhaps half-heartedly attracting an inefficient pollinator is Pawpaw's adaptation to it's own heavy fruit.

Sunday, November 7, 2010

Binoculars for Your Nose

Eastern Witch Hazel is the last tree to bloom in the Midwest. AMcC

I stepped outside on a calm autumn night last week. A fresh, citrus scent was in the air. It reminded me of witch hazel in bloom. That couldn’t be, of course, because my big hybrid witch hazel (Hamamelis x intermedia ‘Arnold Promise”) blooms in February. Then I remembered my other witch hazel tree, a scrawny little guy, completely overshadowed by big brother Arnold and my neighbor’s silver maples. When I bought my home in the 1980s, I knew I wanted a witch hazel tree. I was in love with the one that bloomed by the east wall of the Missouri Botanical Garden in late winter. I knew there was a native variety, but I wasn’t aware of any native plant nurseries in my areas at the time. I ordered Eastern witch hazel (Hamamelis virginiana) from a native plant nursery in the Appalachian Mountains and planted it about the same time as the Asian hybrid. According to Don Kurz’ book, Trees of Missouri, I ended up with a tree that is native to the Ozarks, though not to St. Louis County, Missouri. Two short decades zipped by with only the puniest of blooms, on the slenderest of twigs. Now this fragrance in November…

The next morning I confirmed it; my skinny 12 foot-tree was covered in bloom! The scent is wonderful, but it can be elusive. You can stand right next to a branch in full bloom and not be aware of it. You can be twenty feet away in the dark and know it instantly. Like all scent, it’s hard to describe with words: something like an orange, but lighter. I say full bloom, but that’s “full” by witch hazel standards. The petals are narrow ribbons of yellow, half-inch-long or a bit more. The blooms are often clustered together, without stems. 

With a shovel and a bit of determination, it’s not too hard to remake your perennial border. It’s a little tougher to remedy mistakes with trees and shrubs. If I were to remake the trees in my yard, I’d give my Eastern witch hazel a spot with more light, farther away from it’s winter-blooming relative. Both are covered in golden leaves in fall. One is the last tree of the year to bloom; the other is the first. 

According to John Hilty’s website, “Illinois Wildflowers,” Eastern witch hazel is pollinated by flies, but also a few moths, wasps and beetles. The plant doesn’t need showy petals, streaked with guides to direct butterflies and honey bees to the goodies. It does need scent, and so do I.

Scent may be the most neglected of human senses, but it’s more important than we admit. Grocery store shelves are filled with scented candles, scented oils, scented gel sticks, scented night lights, and scented trash bags. A popular fabric softener comes in 23 different varieties. On their website, you can search by “scent type”: “airy fresh” or “modern exotic.” 100 ml. spray bottles of perfume (3.4 oz) can sell for $100 and up. Gas stations sell air fresheners too. They say “New Car Scent” just flies off the shelf. Fragrance is of the essence in the garden for both humans and pollinators, as I mentioned in “Creatures of the Night.” It might be nice to have a device to amplify our sense of smell. Binoculars for your nose, perhaps?